|
Replying To Commodore: "I don't think Ulsterman is actually from Ulster, a few years ago I noted and flagged a commonality of wording and spelling which suggested one person had a large number of profiles on here purporting to be from a wide variety of places.
Ulsterman (Antrim), Banisteoir (National), Cbar (Mayo) and a few others are the same person, there are a number of other profiles too.
It seems its actually Carlow poster behind them all." Thats 2 Jonnies Catfish territory you are entering now
Southsham (Limerick) - Posts: 740 - 12/02/2025 17:41:47
2590779
Link
1
|
|
Replying To supersub15: "That's a loaded statement Commodore and an opinion that you are entitled to. I do not have any problems with your opinion at all, however, it's the suggestive part of your post that doesn't sit well with me, can I ask you to confirm / deny if I am that Carlow poster, feel free to reply, if you decide not to reply I will take it that I am that "Carlow poster that is behind them all."" In my earlier post I mentioned that a few years back I noted that Ulsterman (Antrim) had a tendency to type in distinctive way, and I noted a few others at the time using the same distinctive typing habit.
From memory, those posters were Bainisteoir (National), Cbar (Mayo) and at least one other (Need to check old notes), and when I highlighted it to Ulsterman, I immediately noticed that distinctive pattern immediately stopped for all of the posters. That to me confirmed they were likely the same poster.
While I can't definitively state where any poster is really from or located, Bainisteoir (National) tends to post mainly on the Carlow GAA thread on here, so strong probability that that poster is a Carlow GAA fan.
Commodore (Donegal) - Posts: 1266 - 13/02/2025 17:17:12
2590868
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Commodore: " Replying To supersub15: "That's a loaded statement Commodore and an opinion that you are entitled to. I do not have any problems with your opinion at all, however, it's the suggestive part of your post that doesn't sit well with me, can I ask you to confirm / deny if I am that Carlow poster, feel free to reply, if you decide not to reply I will take it that I am that "Carlow poster that is behind them all."" In my earlier post I mentioned that a few years back I noted that Ulsterman (Antrim) had a tendency to type in distinctive way, and I noted a few others at the time using the same distinctive typing habit. From memory, those posters were Bainisteoir (National), Cbar (Mayo) and at least one other (Need to check old notes), and when I highlighted it to Ulsterman, I immediately noticed that distinctive pattern immediately stopped for all of the posters. That to me confirmed they were likely the same poster. While I can't definitively state where any poster is really from or located, Bainisteoir (National) tends to post mainly on the Carlow GAA thread on here, so strong probability that that poster is a Carlow GAA fan."
Thanks again and take care.
supersub15 (Carlow) - Posts: 3109 - 14/02/2025 08:39:53
2590922
Link
0
|
|
Replying To supersub15: " Replying To Commodore: "[quote=supersub15: "That's a loaded statement Commodore and an opinion that you are entitled to. I do not have any problems with your opinion at all, however, it's the suggestive part of your post that doesn't sit well with me, can I ask you to confirm / deny if I am that Carlow poster, feel free to reply, if you decide not to reply I will take it that I am that "Carlow poster that is behind them all."" In my earlier post I mentioned that a few years back I noted that Ulsterman (Antrim) had a tendency to type in distinctive way, and I noted a few others at the time using the same distinctive typing habit. From memory, those posters were Bainisteoir (National), Cbar (Mayo) and at least one other (Need to check old notes), and when I highlighted it to Ulsterman, I immediately noticed that distinctive pattern immediately stopped for all of the posters. That to me confirmed they were likely the same poster. While I can't definitively state where any poster is really from or located, Bainisteoir (National) tends to post mainly on the Carlow GAA thread on here, so strong probability that that poster is a Carlow GAA fan."
Thanks again and take care."]I didn't mention your profile supersub15 in my earlier posts, and to be fair, I didn't question the integrity of posts on HS by posters mentioned. I just don't believe one profile who claims to be from Ulster, is genuinely from Ulster, based on distinct similarities to other profiles and recent activity.
Commodore (Donegal) - Posts: 1266 - 14/02/2025 11:13:29
2590938
Link
0
|
|
Very few in County Derry support Derry city but I know some in Strabane too.
I must question your usage of the term "Northern Irish" in your post. You should be aware that identity is a sensitive issue and many of us don't like that term being used to address us. You must know that many of us didn't tick that box on the census yet we still get that term forced on us.
PattyONeill (Derry) - Posts: 255 - 14/02/2025 18:55:10
2591046
Link
0
|
|
Replying To PattyONeill: "Very few in County Derry support Derry city but I know some in Strabane too.
I must question your usage of the term "Northern Irish" in your post. You should be aware that identity is a sensitive issue and many of us don't like that term being used to address us. You must know that many of us didn't tick that box on the census yet we still get that term forced on us." Exactly Patty that term is an insult to many.
HurlingObserver (Down) - Posts: 66 - 14/02/2025 22:37:42
2591080
Link
0
|
|
Not surprised by this arrangement atall , it is as someone mentioned a win, win situation. Derry City would have a largely nationalist following with a healthy overlap between those attending Celtic Park and the Brandywell (550m apart) for match going fans from within the city itself. It was noticeable during Derry's recent success that the 'soccer influence' grew within their multiplying support e.g. jeering the opposing kick out etc. Hope the proposed use of the centre of excellence won't impinge on any GAA activities such as training or hosting underage club matches and that a return journey of 40 miles to training won't be off putting for Derry City FC.
Many Derry players have indulged in both codes over the years. Gerry McElhinney had a professional career in soccer after being a prominent Derry player. Tom McGuinness (Martin's brother) was a powerful midfielder with Derry and later played LOI soccer. Eoin Bradley a gifted forward played with 4-5 Irish league clubs. Anthony Tohill had a trial at Arsenal and the great Martin O Neill played Gaelic football at underage for county and college level before embarking on a very successful soccer career.
Curlew66 (Roscommon) - Posts: 584 - 14/02/2025 23:51:25
2591087
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Curlew66: "Not surprised by this arrangement atall , it is as someone mentioned a win, win situation. Derry City would have a largely nationalist following with a healthy overlap between those attending Celtic Park and the Brandywell (550m apart) for match going fans from within the city itself. It was noticeable during Derry's recent success that the 'soccer influence' grew within their multiplying support e.g. jeering the opposing kick out etc. Hope the proposed use of the centre of excellence won't impinge on any GAA activities such as training or hosting underage club matches and that a return journey of 40 miles to training won't be off putting for Derry City FC.
Many Derry players have indulged in both codes over the years. Gerry McElhinney had a professional career in soccer after being a prominent Derry player. Tom McGuinness (Martin's brother) was a powerful midfielder with Derry and later played LOI soccer. Eoin Bradley a gifted forward played with 4-5 Irish league clubs. Anthony Tohill had a trial at Arsenal and the great Martin O Neill played Gaelic football at underage for county and college level before embarking on a very successful soccer career." Sorry, Anthony Tohill had a trial at Man Utd , it was Meath's Graham Geraghty that had a trial at Arsenal.
Curlew66 (Roscommon) - Posts: 584 - 15/02/2025 11:45:54
2591118
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Curlew66: "Not surprised by this arrangement atall , it is as someone mentioned a win, win situation. Derry City would have a largely nationalist following with a healthy overlap between those attending Celtic Park and the Brandywell (550m apart) for match going fans from within the city itself. It was noticeable during Derry's recent success that the 'soccer influence' grew within their multiplying support e.g. jeering the opposing kick out etc. Hope the proposed use of the centre of excellence won't impinge on any GAA activities such as training or hosting underage club matches and that a return journey of 40 miles to training won't be off putting for Derry City FC.
Many Derry players have indulged in both codes over the years. Gerry McElhinney had a professional career in soccer after being a prominent Derry player. Tom McGuinness (Martin's brother) was a powerful midfielder with Derry and later played LOI soccer. Eoin Bradley a gifted forward played with 4-5 Irish league clubs. Anthony Tohill had a trial at Arsenal and the great Martin O Neill played Gaelic football at underage for county and college level before embarking on a very successful soccer career." Kevin Doyle played minor football for Wexford.
Eoin Quigley has a champions League cap
Ciaran lyng was at Grimsby
Conal flood was at Sunderland I think
Shane long played minor hurling with Tipp
Niall Quinn played minor hurling for Dublin
Doylerwex (Wexford) - Posts: 3375 - 15/02/2025 13:47:19
2591135
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Curlew66: "Sorry, Anthony Tohill had a trial at Man Utd , it was Meath's Graham Geraghty that had a trial at Arsenal." Tohill in midfield and Geraghty at right half back in their prime were some players. Up there with some of the best ever in their positions. Apparently Paul Merson could not believe how fit the amature player Graham Geraghty was when he arrived in Arsenal. He seemed to have an extra gear at times at right half back. (Similar to James Mc Carthy)
letsgetgoing (Roscommon) - Posts: 671 - 15/02/2025 14:01:21
2591138
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Doylerwex: "Kevin Doyle played minor football for Wexford.
Eoin Quigley has a champions League cap
Ciaran lyng was at Grimsby
Conal flood was at Sunderland I think
Shane long played minor hurling with Tipp
Niall Quinn played minor hurling for Dublin" Shane Long didn't just play minor hurling for Tipp, he played 2 years minor and was their best player. He scored 4-4 in 2 successive Munster minor hurling finals!
Stephen Hunt hurled u15 and u16 with Waterford.
Dessie Hutchinson played for Brighton.
Ciaran Lyng played for Preston didn't he?
Viking66 (Wexford) - Posts: 14821 - 15/02/2025 14:25:06
2591140
Link
0
|
|
Replying To PattyONeill: "Very few in County Derry support Derry city but I know some in Strabane too.
I must question your usage of the term "Northern Irish" in your post. You should be aware that identity is a sensitive issue and many of us don't like that term being used to address us. You must know that many of us didn't tick that box on the census yet we still get that term forced on us." I seem to remember calling you out a few months ago for using the term "northern Ireland" in relation to the Casement Park debate. If my memory serves me right you said that the best place for the new stadium was somewhere in the centre of " Northern Ireland " whilst totally dis-regarding Cavan , Monaghan and Donegal. Better late than never I suppose.
tireoghainabu (Tyrone) - Posts: 362 - 15/02/2025 15:12:33
2591145
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Doylerwex: "Kevin Doyle played minor football for Wexford.
Eoin Quigley has a champions League cap
Ciaran lyng was at Grimsby
Conal flood was at Sunderland I think
Shane long played minor hurling with Tipp
Niall Quinn played minor hurling for Dublin" Kevin Doyle never played minor football for Wexford. Not to be name-dropping about the sort of rubbing shoulders I do from time to time, but he's told me this himself. Says the closest he ever came to it was playing under Aidan O'Brien for Good Counsel while he went to school there.
The story that he played for Wexford is one of those urban myths like how the Brazilian soccer legend Socrates allegedly played for UCD or Shelburne reserves (depending on who's telling it) while studying in Dublin. He never even studied in Dublin at all.
Pikeman96 (Wexford) - Posts: 2693 - 15/02/2025 15:33:41
2591147
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Doylerwex: "Kevin Doyle played minor football for Wexford.
Eoin Quigley has a champions League cap
Ciaran lyng was at Grimsby
Conal flood was at Sunderland I think
Shane long played minor hurling with Tipp
Niall Quinn played minor hurling for Dublin" Kevin Moran won 2 All-Ireland Senior Football Championships with Dublin and 2 FA Cup finals with Manchester United.
Cockney_Cat (UK) - Posts: 2687 - 15/02/2025 16:25:24
2591154
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Cockney_Cat: "Kevin Moran won 2 All-Ireland Senior Football Championships with Dublin and 2 FA Cup finals with Manchester United." Kevin was a warrior. Had great pace in his younger days, fearless and big hearted at centre half. All round good fella, a gentleman.
Curlew66 (Roscommon) - Posts: 584 - 15/02/2025 20:29:34
2591214
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Curlew66: "Sorry, Anthony Tohill had a trial at Man Utd , it was Meath's Graham Geraghty that had a trial at Arsenal." Tohill had the trial at 23 which was very late. I think he had returned from his spell in the Afl. Played in a reserve game for United in 95. There is some footage on YouTube. I
FoolsGold (Cavan) - Posts: 2860 - 15/02/2025 20:54:08
2591218
Link
0
|
|
Tomsmith here
No matter. Our national game which is called Grab all association by those that follow Soccer is in competition for our youths.
tomsmith (Cavan) - Posts: 4006 - 15/02/2025 23:35:41
2591270
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Curlew66: "Not surprised by this arrangement atall , it is as someone mentioned a win, win situation. Derry City would have a largely nationalist following with a healthy overlap between those attending Celtic Park and the Brandywell (550m apart) for match going fans from within the city itself. It was noticeable during Derry's recent success that the 'soccer influence' grew within their multiplying support e.g. jeering the opposing kick out etc. Hope the proposed use of the centre of excellence won't impinge on any GAA activities such as training or hosting underage club matches and that a return journey of 40 miles to training won't be off putting for Derry City FC.
Many Derry players have indulged in both codes over the years. Gerry McElhinney had a professional career in soccer after being a prominent Derry player. Tom McGuinness (Martin's brother) was a powerful midfielder with Derry and later played LOI soccer. Eoin Bradley a gifted forward played with 4-5 Irish league clubs. Anthony Tohill had a trial at Arsenal and the great Martin O Neill played Gaelic football at underage for county and college level before embarking on a very successful soccer career." I would say that for the majority of the residents of The Lone Moor road what goes on behind the walls of Celtic Park is a complete mystery.You mention one city man in over 50 years i.e. Tom McGuinness who played county football.While there are a few clubs around the city I would say there is no place in Nationalist Ireland where there is so little interest in Gaelic Games.It is a terrible pity that that is the case in a city of 100K people where other aspects of Irish life are very much to the fore.The city's hinterland in Innishowen in Donegal was very similar but in the last 30 years or so the GAA has started to come on in leaps and bounds.
gunman (Donegal) - Posts: 1131 - 16/02/2025 12:04:41
2591310
Link
0
|
|
Replying To gunman: "I would say that for the majority of the residents of The Lone Moor road what goes on behind the walls of Celtic Park is a complete mystery.You mention one city man in over 50 years i.e. Tom McGuinness who played county football.While there are a few clubs around the city I would say there is no place in Nationalist Ireland where there is so little interest in Gaelic Games.It is a terrible pity that that is the case in a city of 100K people where other aspects of Irish life are very much to the fore.The city's hinterland in Innishowen in Donegal was very similar but in the last 30 years or so the GAA has started to come on in leaps and bounds." You want Derry removed from "Nationalist Ireland"?
You can add the towns of Sligo and Athlone too.
Seanfanbocht (Roscommon) - Posts: 2078 - 16/02/2025 19:20:44
2591412
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Seanfanbocht: "You want Derry removed from "Nationalist Ireland"?
You can add the towns of Sligo and Athlone too." I do not understand your jibe about removing Derry from Nationalist Ireland.We all know that being Soccer supporters doesn't make them any less Nationalist.I just used the term Nationalist to describe a demographic that would be available for the promotion of Gaelic games.We know that when resources were put in to Dublin GAA it began to thrive.Maybe something like that needs to happen in Derry.I don't know where Athlone and Sligo come in to it.Have Athlone and St Marys Sligo not been very successful in their respective Senior championships over the years.Anyway I think we would all like to see a stronger Gaa in the city and on a lighter note maybe we could get them to declare for Donegal because the people on the West bank of the city have much more affinity with us than they have with Co Derry
gunman (Donegal) - Posts: 1131 - 17/02/2025 11:07:39
2591535
Link
0
|