National Forum

All Stars

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To Greengrass:  "The same most definitely can be said about you."
I think you'll find on this matter it's you and others from Louth. Seeing as you flat out refuse to accept anything other than Paddy Keenan was the best player in the 2010 championship going by some comments.

oneoff (UK) - Posts: 1472 - 03/11/2024 13:24:24    2578093

Link

Replying To oneoff:  "I think you'll find on this matter it's you and others from Louth. Seeing as you flat out refuse to accept anything other than Paddy Keenan was the best player in the 2010 championship going by some comments."
There's no need for a hissy fit. It's not just people from Louth who disagreed with you and I certainly never said that Paddy Keenan was the best player in the 2010 championship. You're the one who said Paddy Keenan's All Star was the biggest token All Star in the history of the All Stars. People rightly called that statement out for the nonsense it was.

Greengrass (Louth) - Posts: 6142 - 03/11/2024 15:27:50    2578126

Link

Replying To oneoff:  "I think you'll find on this matter it's you and others from Louth. Seeing as you flat out refuse to accept anything other than Paddy Keenan was the best player in the 2010 championship going by some comments."
Oneoff what part of the UK are you from?
A) Slane
B) Duleek
C) Morington
D) Doneycarney
E) All of above

Ollie2 (Louth) - Posts: 904 - 03/11/2024 17:16:55    2578158

Link

Replying To bruffgael:  "Aidan Walsh couldn't cut it as a footballer after a few seasons so he switched to hurling ....."
I'm sure Aidan Walsh was superior in both codes to the likes of you, and in fact he's still performing well at club level today! Seems ridiculous to be talking about all stars of 2010, but Aidan starred in all Ireland win over Down that year. All Stars are invariably handed out primarily to the all Ireland finalists … or in some cases only to the all Ireland winners…as in 2021,when Cork didn't get a single all star award despite contesting all Ireland hurling final!

Ryanteam (Cork) - Posts: 367 - 03/11/2024 18:02:58    2578171

Link

Replying To Greengrass:  "Beggan is better than Morgan. Always has been. Having said that they're the top two in the country."
Should have went to Specsavers

Saynothing (Tyrone) - Posts: 2147 - 03/11/2024 18:17:44    2578180

Link

Replying To Greengrass:  "There's no need for a hissy fit. It's not just people from Louth who disagreed with you and I certainly never said that Paddy Keenan was the best player in the 2010 championship. You're the one who said Paddy Keenan's All Star was the biggest token All Star in the history of the All Stars. People rightly called that statement out for the nonsense it was."
I never said you did I said some.

As for talking nonsense you're the one so desperately trying to justify your point you keep bringing up him being nominated in 2007 and when asked what that has to do with it you unsurprisingly ignore it. Also saying Bernard Brogan saying he was one of the best players he played with again what does that have to do with it? Players much much better than him never won All-Stars but they didn't have the luxury of the pity vote.

Also why is it no one from Louth ever has anything to say about the Dublin game they played after?

oneoff (UK) - Posts: 1472 - 03/11/2024 18:43:05    2578184

Link

louth were bang average v dublin the next day lost by 6 points and went around croke park on a lap of honour! the next year they went out and got bet in first round by carlow and that was the last seen or heard of that Louth team. they were blessed to get an all star in 2010 having won nothing and didnt even go and win their qualifier then to get to a quater final. they were very lucky this year to get one as well, even though that lennon player was excellent all year and hesa super player but there lots of examples of players like that not getting all stars from likes of kerry and dublin and derry this year, dublin and derry should feel most aggrieved not to get 1 between them ahead of louth. lets not forget louth lost to armagh, donegal, cavan and meath in league and finshed 6th.

dickie10 (UK) - Posts: 761 - 03/11/2024 19:04:25    2578190

Link

Replying To dickie10:  "louth were bang average v dublin the next day lost by 6 points and went around croke park on a lap of honour! the next year they went out and got bet in first round by carlow and that was the last seen or heard of that Louth team. they were blessed to get an all star in 2010 having won nothing and didnt even go and win their qualifier then to get to a quater final. they were very lucky this year to get one as well, even though that lennon player was excellent all year and hesa super player but there lots of examples of players like that not getting all stars from likes of kerry and dublin and derry this year, dublin and derry should feel most aggrieved not to get 1 between them ahead of louth. lets not forget louth lost to armagh, donegal, cavan and meath in league and finshed 6th."
They didn't give an All Star award to Louth. They gave it to Craig Lennon.

GreenandRed (Mayo) - Posts: 7622 - 03/11/2024 19:38:43    2578201

Link

Replying To Oldtourman:  "But ti's Walsh's selection most people would dispute, not Paddy Keenan's"
Aidan Walsh had a massive performance for Cork in the 2010 all Ireland football final against Down, and justified his all star award. Cork and Down got 4 awards each that year, but Donncha O' Connor and Daniel Goulding who was man of match in the final, were unlucky to miss out!

Ryanteam (Cork) - Posts: 367 - 04/11/2024 06:52:09    2578251

Link

Replying To foreveryoung:  "Congratulations to all the AS winners, and to POTYs and YPOTYs! Delighted that Limerick received four (CON must have been very close too). Especially happy for Dan Morrissey---a mountain of a man in that defense. Isn't that one at 7, one at 3, and now two at 4? That's the epitome of a great defender.

Nicky was nailed on. Hegarty totally burned down the Munster Championship to get Limerick to an unprecedented 6-in-a-row, and that is some going given the round-robin system and given all the great Cork teams (Lynch and Ring, and Cummins and Barry-Murphy) over the decades that came so close to it!

And anyone who says "I didn't see Kyle getting it" must be fair well blind. Hayes was nominated for HOTY. THAT MEANS THAT HE WAS IN THE TOP 3 HURLERS IN IRELAND FOR 2024. So, why would he not be in the top 15, when he was already in the top 3? It was as plain as the nose on your face that Kyle Hayes was going to win an All-star in 2024. I think that's 5-in-row for Hayes now in the 20's. Reminds me of the great Pat Hartigan in the 70's; the only other Limerick man to put 5 All-Star awards back-to-back. And somehow, I get the impression that Hayes isn't quite finished yet."
I'd say with almost certainty he isnt finished yet. I think were talking about different things though.

Gaelic24 (Donegal) - Posts: 8 - 04/11/2024 07:05:42    2578252

Link

Replying To Saynothing:  "Should have went to Specsavers"
Should have *gone!

HarrietPotter (Leitrim) - Posts: 30 - 04/11/2024 08:01:52    2578259

Link

Replying To dickie10:  "louth were bang average v dublin the next day lost by 6 points and went around croke park on a lap of honour! the next year they went out and got bet in first round by carlow and that was the last seen or heard of that Louth team. they were blessed to get an all star in 2010 having won nothing and didnt even go and win their qualifier then to get to a quater final. they were very lucky this year to get one as well, even though that lennon player was excellent all year and hesa super player but there lots of examples of players like that not getting all stars from likes of kerry and dublin and derry this year, dublin and derry should feel most aggrieved not to get 1 between them ahead of louth. lets not forget louth lost to armagh, donegal, cavan and meath in league and finshed 6th."
A Meath man for sure

Shearer (Louth) - Posts: 879 - 04/11/2024 13:04:20    2578317

Link

Replying To Shearer:  "A Meath man for sure"
I was thinking the same but if he was a Meath man, then he would surely remember the team 'that was not heard about again after 2011' hammering Meath in Navan and relegating them in 2012. Unless he is just suffering from Post Traumatic Stress since Iniskeen....

LaLu (Louth) - Posts: 235 - 04/11/2024 17:57:59    2578383

Link

Replying To oneoff:  "I never said you did I said some.

As for talking nonsense you're the one so desperately trying to justify your point you keep bringing up him being nominated in 2007 and when asked what that has to do with it you unsurprisingly ignore it. Also saying Bernard Brogan saying he was one of the best players he played with again what does that have to do with it? Players much much better than him never won All-Stars but they didn't have the luxury of the pity vote.

Also why is it no one from Louth ever has anything to say about the Dublin game they played after?"
Peter Canavan said that day after Dublin beat Kouth in 2010 that the heart and soul had been ripped out of the Louth team on the day of the Leinster Final and he was right. The nomination for Paddy Keenan in 2007 shows that he was regarded very highly before 2010. Bernard Brogan also holds him in the highest regard as a player. He was an exceptional player and he fully deserved his All Star in 2010. You're just a bluffer with a chip on your shoulder.

Greengrass (Louth) - Posts: 6142 - 04/11/2024 18:56:14    2578394

Link