|
Replying To iarmhiabu: "The year after St Brigid's won the All Ireland, something that eluded Garrycastle. Do you not think Loman's have had an easy ride in Leinster this year, winning their 2 games to date by a combination of 26 points?" The problem is Lomans are rarely tested in Westmeath
valley84 (Westmeath) - Posts: 1900 - 20/11/2024 18:38:59
2580489
Link
0
|
|
Replying To valley84: "The problem is Lomans are rarely tested in Westmeath" That's not true!
Lost 2018 final
Lost 2019 final
Won 2020 final After ET
Won 2021 final After Replay and ET
Lost 2022 final
Won 2023 final by 2 points
Won 2024 final After Replay, ET and Penalties
Temple56 (Westmeath) - Posts: 513 - 20/11/2024 19:23:26
2580493
Link
1
|
|
Replying To valley84: "The problem is Lomans are rarely tested in Westmeath" St Loman's had the second worst defence if I remember correctly in the group, conceding calamitous goals to average teams. The difference was they had a set of county forwards to bail them out in every game. Paddy Dowdall has clearly been working hard to improve their defensive structure. The Downs severely tested St Loman's twice, pound for pound they are as good as them.
iarmhiabu (Westmeath) - Posts: 100 - 21/11/2024 12:44:23
2580563
Link
0
|
|
I would agree the downs and St Lomans are of a similar standard. 2 quality teams. It's great to have 2 teams of that quality in the county at the moment.
Lakecounty94 (Westmeath) - Posts: 65 - 21/11/2024 13:58:19
2580575
Link
1
|
|
Lomans gets an awful bad wrap, They will more than likely win a good few more westmeath senior championships before the tide changes, where does it change to? thats the problem nowhere visible at the minute. So therefore they will go down as one of Westmeath Greatest teams winning more championships than the strong Athlone Team, Shamrocks and Garrycastle. People saying there defense is no good, a forward line sells admission tickets, a defense wins championships, Maybe there defense is underrated greatly?
In all Honesty whos going to stop Lomans winning 5 out of the next 6 Championships, The Downs might win 1-2, Kinnegad not by the looks of it, Shamrocks i cannot see it although underage is back strong again, Tyrllesspass seem to be hanging on and hanging on well to be fair to them, Shandonagh too hit and miss and turnover of players is high. From south Westmeath, Athlone will be intermediate before winning senior again, Garrycastle might never win one for decades, Moate could challenge in a few years but again could go the other way. Caulry might think they can challenge but 1 semi final here and there probably not enough to warrant a real case. Tubberclare underage booming but havent been able to put it together at intermediate level, Tang had there couple of years but just dont have the player pool. The hurling influenced teams like Killucan and Malachys once in a blue moon might get it together and make a semi final.
There might be one team to come out of nowhere and win one, seems to happen in other countys but when was the last time it happened in senior championship in Westmeath ??? Castledaly 2006 but were in 3 finals before that, Kinnegad in 1996 or Rosemount in the 80s.
PowellJohn3 (Westmeath) - Posts: 59 - 21/11/2024 14:29:05
2580583
Link
1
|
|
Replying To PowellJohn3: "Lomans gets an awful bad wrap, They will more than likely win a good few more westmeath senior championships before the tide changes, where does it change to? thats the problem nowhere visible at the minute. So therefore they will go down as one of Westmeath Greatest teams winning more championships than the strong Athlone Team, Shamrocks and Garrycastle. People saying there defense is no good, a forward line sells admission tickets, a defense wins championships, Maybe there defense is underrated greatly?
In all Honesty whos going to stop Lomans winning 5 out of the next 6 Championships, The Downs might win 1-2, Kinnegad not by the looks of it, Shamrocks i cannot see it although underage is back strong again, Tyrllesspass seem to be hanging on and hanging on well to be fair to them, Shandonagh too hit and miss and turnover of players is high. From south Westmeath, Athlone will be intermediate before winning senior again, Garrycastle might never win one for decades, Moate could challenge in a few years but again could go the other way. Caulry might think they can challenge but 1 semi final here and there probably not enough to warrant a real case. Tubberclare underage booming but havent been able to put it together at intermediate level, Tang had there couple of years but just dont have the player pool. The hurling influenced teams like Killucan and Malachys once in a blue moon might get it together and make a semi final.
There might be one team to come out of nowhere and win one, seems to happen in other countys but when was the last time it happened in senior championship in Westmeath ??? Castledaly 2006 but were in 3 finals before that, Kinnegad in 1996 or Rosemount in the 80s." Realistically Lomans will be automatic contenders for the next 5-10 years but things can change very very quickly. I think Kinnegad's time has passed. The Downs will be around for a while. Shamrocks will be back eventually and Athlone are starting to look good enough. Championship's are always hard won though. The only title Lomans coasted to was 2015
Bluelake (Westmeath) - Posts: 173 - 21/11/2024 14:41:08
2580592
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Bluelake: "Realistically Lomans will be automatic contenders for the next 5-10 years but things can change very very quickly. I think Kinnegad's time has passed. The Downs will be around for a while. Shamrocks will be back eventually and Athlone are starting to look good enough. Championship's are always hard won though. The only title Lomans coasted to was 2015" And even in 2015 , in the semi final Shamrocks missed 3 open goals in the first half before Lomans won well in the second. But they absolutely sail to the semi final every year. Nobody else can do that. They'll win at least 3 of the next 5. The other question above about when a team last came from nowhere. I'd say it was The Downs 2003. They hadn't even made a semi final in ages prior to that.
jamsie (Westmeath) - Posts: 463 - 21/11/2024 15:03:06
2580598
Link
0
|
|
Replying To PowellJohn3: "Lomans gets an awful bad wrap, They will more than likely win a good few more westmeath senior championships before the tide changes, where does it change to? thats the problem nowhere visible at the minute. So therefore they will go down as one of Westmeath Greatest teams winning more championships than the strong Athlone Team, Shamrocks and Garrycastle. People saying there defense is no good, a forward line sells admission tickets, a defense wins championships, Maybe there defense is underrated greatly?
In all Honesty whos going to stop Lomans winning 5 out of the next 6 Championships, The Downs might win 1-2, Kinnegad not by the looks of it, Shamrocks i cannot see it although underage is back strong again, Tyrllesspass seem to be hanging on and hanging on well to be fair to them, Shandonagh too hit and miss and turnover of players is high. From south Westmeath, Athlone will be intermediate before winning senior again, Garrycastle might never win one for decades, Moate could challenge in a few years but again could go the other way. Caulry might think they can challenge but 1 semi final here and there probably not enough to warrant a real case. Tubberclare underage booming but havent been able to put it together at intermediate level, Tang had there couple of years but just dont have the player pool. The hurling influenced teams like Killucan and Malachys once in a blue moon might get it together and make a semi final.
There might be one team to come out of nowhere and win one, seems to happen in other countys but when was the last time it happened in senior championship in Westmeath ??? Castledaly 2006 but were in 3 finals before that, Kinnegad in 1996 or Rosemount in the 80s." St Loman's are going nowhere by the look of things, their only serious challengers next year again are The Downs and potentially Kinnegad. I'm not saying the St Loman's defence is no good but they needed to brush up big time after conceding 7 goals to Athlone, Caulry, Tang and Tyrrellspass. Ultimately St Loman's have been better in attack. I'm not sure if Sir Alex Ferguson's defence wins championships quote applies to gaelic football, Kinnegad's defence was outrageously good this year although they could have won it last year. Teams need to be strong at both ends of the pitch.
iarmhiabu (Westmeath) - Posts: 100 - 21/11/2024 16:16:27
2580610
Link
0
|
|
Replying To iarmhiabu: "St Loman's had the second worst defence if I remember correctly in the group, conceding calamitous goals to average teams. The difference was they had a set of county forwards to bail them out in every game. Paddy Dowdall has clearly been working hard to improve their defensive structure. The Downs severely tested St Loman's twice, pound for pound they are as good as them." The difference is that Loman's have multiple championships won in the past ten years, The Downs have won one championship since 2005, to suggest they're at similar levels is not borne out by that ultimate criteria.
Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 1916 - 21/11/2024 17:16:19
2580626
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Bluelake: "Realistically Lomans will be automatic contenders for the next 5-10 years but things can change very very quickly. I think Kinnegad's time has passed. The Downs will be around for a while. Shamrocks will be back eventually and Athlone are starting to look good enough. Championship's are always hard won though. The only title Lomans coasted to was 2015" Athlone's issue is the conveyor belt of talent coming through to challenge their senior side, they're not competing at Div 1 level at underage. Loman's are likely to win the under 20 championship and not one of those players is in contention to start on Saturday. They have a young senior side with one or two exceptions
Claretandblue (Westmeath) - Posts: 1916 - 21/11/2024 17:20:46
2580627
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Claretandblue: "The difference is that Loman's have multiple championships won in the past ten years, The Downs have won one championship since 2005, to suggest they're at similar levels is not borne out by that ultimate criteria." I'm not talking about the last 10 years though. My comments are in response to a poster saying St Loman's haven't really been tested in Westmeath, he must have forgotten about the manner in which they won the county title.
iarmhiabu (Westmeath) - Posts: 100 - 21/11/2024 21:20:45
2580654
Link
0
|
|
Replying To Claretandblue: "Athlone's issue is the conveyor belt of talent coming through to challenge their senior side, they're not competing at Div 1 level at underage. Loman's are likely to win the under 20 championship and not one of those players is in contention to start on Saturday. They have a young senior side with one or two exceptions" Careful now, St Loman's were likely to win the Junior championship too!!
iarmhiabu (Westmeath) - Posts: 100 - 21/11/2024 21:22:20
2580655
Link
0
|
|
St lomans summary of this forum has gone from there shocking defensively only they've an inter county forward line to get them out of jail , they are a defensive team yet top scorers in Westmeath and winning both Leinster games by a aggregate of 27 points 14 point victory in navan and a 13 point victory last week so that explains the defensive football they play and now there very good defensively , thank god none of us posters are pundits or have a managerial job.
But on a serious note the very best of luck to players management coaches and supports of St Lomans Garrycastle and of course Castletown/Geohegan let's hope we've 3 lake county teams in Leinster finals next weekend.
TheGaaMan77 (Westmeath) - Posts: 66 - 21/11/2024 23:19:22
2580663
Link
0
|