National Forum

Galway Football thread

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Replying To jm25:  "Some abomination of nonsense by Sean odomhnaill on maroon and white pod with north and west divide.

Now it's bad form if u20s were training in glan but plenty training done in Pearse too"
I listened to it - didnt think it was nonsense. What exactly did you disagree with?

The_DOC (Galway) - Posts: 756 - 11/04/2025 12:19:11    2601496

Link

Replying To The_DOC:  "I listened to it - didnt think it was nonsense. What exactly did you disagree with?"
Certainly the journey difficulty eg Moycullen/knocknacarra to loughgeorge is similar as glan williamstown.

Also training takes place in salthill a lot which would be tough journey for north Galway clubs.

Also he said team selection is 3/1 north he insinuated spread was too high north which is nonsense 5 of team was west Wednesday so it is 2/1.

Also it's irrelevant where they are from but it was the midfield of 2 west players that was biggest issue in team and I feel a change should have been made there across the 4 games

He also believes LOC performances puts him in position for a starting corner forward spot on team which I would disagree with also.

jm25 (Galway) - Posts: 1440 - 11/04/2025 12:45:35    2601500

Link

Replying To jm25:  "Certainly the journey difficulty eg Moycullen/knocknacarra to loughgeorge is similar as glan williamstown.

Also training takes place in salthill a lot which would be tough journey for north Galway clubs.

Also he said team selection is 3/1 north he insinuated spread was too high north which is nonsense 5 of team was west Wednesday so it is 2/1.

Also it's irrelevant where they are from but it was the midfield of 2 west players that was biggest issue in team and I feel a change should have been made there across the 4 games

He also believes LOC performances puts him in position for a starting corner forward spot on team which I would disagree with also."
Yeah no thats Fair enough on some of those points, I'll concede on a few (SÓD can say some mad stuff at times!)...BUT its not that straightforward at the same time:

Certainly the journey difficulty eg. Moycullen/knocknacarra to loughgeorge is similar as glan williamstown.
- Yes but I think he was say its harder for the clubs west of Spidéal (MB, C Rua, L Mor, CC etc.)

Also training takes place in salthill a lot which would be tough journey for north Galway clubs.
- Its a 90min drive from C Rua and closer to 2 hours from Clifden

Also he said team selection is 3/1 north he insinuated spread was too high north which is nonsense 5 of team was west Wednesday so it is 2/1.
- I dont agree that there is an team selection bias, at least I hope not. Some years will see more representation than others.

Also it's irrelevant where they are from but it was the midfield of 2 west players that was biggest issue in team and I feel a change should have been made there across the 4 game
- Totally Agree

He also believes LOC performances puts him in position for a starting corner forward spot on team which I would disagree with also.
- If hes going well hes def a contender. Hes call but for whatever reason has shown full potential at IC, but his ceiling is very high (I will admit, I am biased here though!).

The_DOC (Galway) - Posts: 756 - 11/04/2025 13:18:06    2601506

Link

Replying To jm25:  "Certainly the journey difficulty eg Moycullen/knocknacarra to loughgeorge is similar as glan williamstown.

Also training takes place in salthill a lot which would be tough journey for north Galway clubs.

Also he said team selection is 3/1 north he insinuated spread was too high north which is nonsense 5 of team was west Wednesday so it is 2/1.

Also it's irrelevant where they are from but it was the midfield of 2 west players that was biggest issue in team and I feel a change should have been made there across the 4 games

He also believes LOC performances puts him in position for a starting corner forward spot on team which I would disagree with also."
Firstly, his distance to training argument is null and void, as the vast majority of u20s would be travelling to training/matches from where they're based in college, not their home.

Secondly, if he thinks LOC or COC, or FOL, or any other Connemara based forward who was given a chance recently, has done anything to warrant inclusion in a championship XV.... Sean is seriously deluded.

streaker (Galway) - Posts: 510 - 11/04/2025 13:42:57    2601511

Link

Replying To jm25:  "Some abomination of nonsense by Sean odomhnaill on maroon and white pod with north and west divide.

Now it's bad form if u20s were training in glan but plenty training done in Pearse too"
Why are they training in glan ???

Kew (Galway) - Posts: 154 - 11/04/2025 16:32:50    2601526

Link

Replying To The_DOC:  "Yeah no thats Fair enough on some of those points, I'll concede on a few (SÓD can say some mad stuff at times!)...BUT its not that straightforward at the same time:

Certainly the journey difficulty eg. Moycullen/knocknacarra to loughgeorge is similar as glan williamstown.
- Yes but I think he was say its harder for the clubs west of Spidéal (MB, C Rua, L Mor, CC etc.)

Also training takes place in salthill a lot which would be tough journey for north Galway clubs.
- Its a 90min drive from C Rua and closer to 2 hours from Clifden

Also he said team selection is 3/1 north he insinuated spread was too high north which is nonsense 5 of team was west Wednesday so it is 2/1.
- I dont agree that there is an team selection bias, at least I hope not. Some years will see more representation than others.

Also it's irrelevant where they are from but it was the midfield of 2 west players that was biggest issue in team and I feel a change should have been made there across the 4 game
- Totally Agree

He also believes LOC performances puts him in position for a starting corner forward spot on team which I would disagree with also.
- If hes going well hes def a contender. Hes call but for whatever reason has shown full potential at IC, but his ceiling is very high (I will admit, I am biased here though!)."
Any Journey that involves crossing the river and crossing the City is painful. We in the NB rightly moan about it every time we have to endure it to attend a match as supporters. But there is no solution. The manager has to balance it between Claregalway and Salthill.

giveitlong (Galway) - Posts: 1271 - 11/04/2025 17:48:14    2601533

Link

Replying To giveitlong:  "Any Journey that involves crossing the river and crossing the City is painful. We in the NB rightly moan about it every time we have to endure it to attend a match as supporters. But there is no solution. The manager has to balance it between Claregalway and Salthill."
That's it exactly.
The management should try and balance where the training is. There's no easy solution in a big county/" like Galway.
Also given the time of year involved pre season - it's not that easy to find pitches for training when the weather is bad so they're hamstring ti some extent there by availability of pitches.
At academy level below minor the teams are regionalised

galwayman2 (Galway) - Posts: 1305 - 12/04/2025 08:33:55    2601559

Link

Recently watched Antoine O Laoi play for An Spideal and I can honestly say he looks the player he was a few years back during the league when on the senior panel...absolutely flying, not sure how he hasn't been asked back in, a better scoring option than his brother.

WonTon5 (Galway) - Posts: 34 - 12/04/2025 09:08:20    2601561

Link

Replying To WonTon5:  "Recently watched Antoine O Laoi play for An Spideal and I can honestly say he looks the player he was a few years back during the league when on the senior panel...absolutely flying, not sure how he hasn't been asked back in, a better scoring option than his brother."
Don't think FOL is there for his scoring. If he could score he'd be an all star. Work rate is top class, but his shooting is terrible.

AOL was playing in the dev panel last year for the fbd i think. Good to hear he's going well. Bad time with injuries

Mayonman (Galway) - Posts: 1917 - 13/04/2025 15:48:40    2601702

Link

Replying To Mayonman:  "Don't think FOL is there for his scoring. If he could score he'd be an all star. Work rate is top class, but his shooting is terrible.

AOL was playing in the dev panel last year for the fbd i think. Good to hear he's going well. Bad time with injuries"
I actually think f o Laoi woukd be half descent option as wing back he very quick around fiend good kick passer but unfortunately not able score

Kickitout (Galway) - Posts: 1045 - 13/04/2025 18:36:55    2601717

Link

Replying To Kickitout:  "I actually think f o Laoi woukd be half descent option as wing back he very quick around fiend good kick passer but unfortunately not able score"
mchugh-molloy-hernon-o'flaherty-kelly-silke-mulkerrins-sweeney would all be picked ahead of him

cavan.galway (Galway) - Posts: 228 - 14/04/2025 10:12:55    2601788

Link

If everyone available team I'd go with for Sunday
Gleeson
Mcgrath
Fitzgerald
Silke
Mchugh
Kelly
Molloy
Conroy
Maher
Tierney
Walsh
Cooke
Finnerty
Comer
Thompson

Dunmore10 (Galway) - Posts: 156 - 14/04/2025 11:22:01    2601811

Link

Replying To Dunmore10:  "If everyone available team I'd go with for Sunday
Gleeson
Mcgrath
Fitzgerald
Silke
Mchugh
Kelly
Molloy
Conroy
Maher
Tierney
Walsh
Cooke
Finnerty
Comer
Thompson"
As Joyce said Cooke won't be available until the All Ireland series. Not sure on John Daly but if available he would start.

Connor Gleeson;
Johnny McGrath, Sean Fitzgerald, Liam Silke
Dylan McHugh, John Daly Sean Kelly;
Matthew Tierney, John Maher;
Cillian McDaid, Paul Conroy Cein Darcy;
Rob Finnerty, Damien Comer Shane Walsh


Jack Glynn,Cian Hernon,Kieran Molloy,Matthew Thompson,Daniel O'Flaherty to bring on

Drax_the_destroyer (UK) - Posts: 365 - 14/04/2025 13:33:19    2601842

Link

Back from the buzz of NYC and now the real battle begins. I know for certain that the Rossies are strongly, strongly expecting to ambush us on Sunday. They're absolutely loving going into this as outsiders. There's already plenty of quiet debate over there as to where the Connacht final v Mayo should be, McHale or The Hyde. I ain't making this up! There's only one answer to that, lads! Bring it on. Gaillimh Abú!!

togoutlads (Galway) - Posts: 1038 - 14/04/2025 14:23:44    2601858

Link

Back from the buzz of NYC and now the real battle begins. I know for certain that the Rossies are strongly, strongly expecting to ambush us on Sunday. They're absolutely loving going into this as outsiders. There's already plenty of quiet debate over there as to where the Connacht final v Mayo should be, McHale or The Hyde. I ain't making this up! There's only one answer to that, lads! Bring it on. Gaillimh Abú!!

togoutlads (Galway) - Posts: 1038 - 14/04/2025 14:32:11    2601862

Link

Lads where is Jack Glynn, is he injured or where has he gone?

The_DOC (Galway) - Posts: 756 - 14/04/2025 14:38:00    2601863

Link

Galway are 2/7 on to win this Sunday with a winning margin of 4-6 Points at least according to the bookies and their punters hard to argue with that, I expect myself Galway to win by a minimum 5 points on Sunday.

Gaa_lover (USA) - Posts: 3576 - 14/04/2025 15:43:35    2601878

Link

Team I think mighr start Sunday
Flahery
McGrath. Fitzgerald. Silke
Mchugh. Kelly. Hernon
Maher / Mcdaid
Tierney. Walsh. O flaherty
Finnerty. Comer. Thompson
It could be fairly close game Gslway are conceding lots of scores last 4 matches , Tyrone , dubs Kerry and New York need to get back to defending better as a unit ideally not more than 16 scores

Kickitout (Galway) - Posts: 1045 - 14/04/2025 16:36:18    2601885

Link

Replying To Kickitout:  "Team I think mighr start Sunday
Flahery
McGrath. Fitzgerald. Silke
Mchugh. Kelly. Hernon
Maher / Mcdaid
Tierney. Walsh. O flaherty
Finnerty. Comer. Thompson
It could be fairly close game Gslway are conceding lots of scores last 4 matches , Tyrone , dubs Kerry and New York need to get back to defending better as a unit ideally not more than 16 scores"
Think people need to realise teams are going to concede higher scores.

There is very little difference to hurling scores. 20pts won't be enough in most games look at Cavan and Wicklow at weekend

Even with defensive football last few years scores have never been higher.

jm25 (Galway) - Posts: 1440 - 14/04/2025 16:58:26    2601887

Link

Replying To jm25:  "Think people need to realise teams are going to concede higher scores.

There is very little difference to hurling scores. 20pts won't be enough in most games look at Cavan and Wicklow at weekend

Even with defensive football last few years scores have never been higher."
Yes agreed and have seen it on a few forums with a few posters going on about how they are conceding too much. That is the very nature of the game now under these rules It's a forwards game now and I pity defenders who have getting little or no protection.

Drax_the_destroyer (UK) - Posts: 365 - 14/04/2025 19:56:27    2601933

Link